Chargeback guide
A customer cancelled but was charged again — what now?
The processor wants the terms the customer agreed to and the cancellation timeline.
What this dispute type means
This dispute says the customer cancelled a subscription and was then charged for a period after that.
The processor is weighing two things: the terms the customer agreed to at signup, and the dates — when they cancelled against when you billed.
What evidence typically helps
- The signup confirmation showing the terms the customer acceptedThe email or screen where the customer accepted the plan, including the billing frequency and the amount.
- Your cancellation policy as it was presented at signupSend the policy as it was shown at signup, not as it reads now — and if it has changed since, say so.
- Records showing when any cancellation request actually arrived relative to the billed periodA timestamped cancellation record next to the billing date settles most of these cases one way or the other.
- Proof the service was provided during the billed period (logins, deliveries, usage)Logins, usage, deliveries or support contacts during the period show the customer was still using what they paid for.
What weak evidence looks like
The one thing to get right: The date ordering is everything: a cancellation before the billing date reads very differently from one after it.
- A policy saying cancellations must be made in writing only helps if you can show the customer was told that and had a way to do it.
- If the cancellation request arrived before the charge, don't argue about the terms — refund the period and say so.
How the respond-by deadline works
Pull the cancellation timestamps first. If they show the request arrived before the charge, your response is a refund rather than a defence, and that is usually quicker than a dispute.
The respond-by date comes from the chargeback notice your processor sent you. That date is the one that matters, and meeting it is yours to do — nothing on this site files a response for you or buys you more time.
You respond through your processor's own portal, dashboard or process, using the case reference they gave you. If the notice doesn't state a deadline, or you can't find it, ask your processor before the window closes.
Build the response early enough that you aren't choosing between sending it late and sending it thin. If you're close to the deadline, send your strongest evidence first rather than waiting for a complete file.
What a good response letter contains
- Give the billing date and the cancellation date side by side.
- Quote the terms the customer accepted at signup, and where they were shown.
- Show usage or delivery during the billed period if the cancellation came after the charge.
Whichever dispute type it is, the letter also needs:
- The case reference and the disputed amount in the first two lines, so the reader knows which case this is.
- One short paragraph on what was sold and when — facts only, no adjectives.
- The evidence listed in the order it supports your account, each item named and dated.
- A closing line stating what you're asking for, without predicting the outcome.
- Your business details and a contact for follow-up questions.
Fighting one right now? Log your case in about ten minutes.
Chargeback Combat writes your side of the case down as one organised record — the reference, the dates, the respond-by deadline and the evidence you hold — and drafts a response letter you review, edit and send yourself.
We organise and draft. We don't file your response with your processor or the card network, and nobody here can promise a particular outcome — that decision is between you, your customer and the network.
General guidance only — networks and processors differ, and your processor's own instructions always take precedence.
Other dispute types
- A customer says the order never arrived — what now?The customer says nothing arrived. Delivery proof is the whole case.
- A customer says the item wasn't as described — what now?They say it wasn't what was advertised. Show the listing and the order side by side.
- A customer says a service wasn't delivered or was cancelled — what now?The work wasn't delivered, or they cancelled. Build the story from the contract and the timeline.
- A customer says they were charged twice — what now?Two charges on one statement? Prove they are separate sales — or refund one.
- A customer says they don't recognise the charge — what now?The cardholder says they never bought it. Show the sale really was theirs.
- A customer says their refund never arrived — what now?They say the refund never arrived. Show the paper trail in order.
Not sure which one fits? Start from all dispute guides.